THE COMING SUBJECTION OF MAN.
by Elizabeth Bisland
(1861-1929)
MY
knowledge of literary form is so slight that it is with great
diffidence I take up my pen, and were it not for the importance of
what I have to say I should not dare attempt so unusual a feat as
writing an article for a magazine. But the discovery I have stumbled
upon is so curious and important that, despite my misgivings,
I feel that my duty to humanity requires I should make it public.
My course at the university was a scientific one, and since leaving
the academic shades my time and attention have been entirely
devoted to the study of the habits and functions of insects. Men
eminent in science have seen fit to speak in terms of praise concerning
two papers I have read before the Academy of Sciences, on the
"Social Economy of Bees," and "The Importance of the Antennæ
in Communications between Insects." They were too technical to
appeal to the unscientific world, so that I have not the consciousness
of familiarity with my public to support me under the ordeal
of appearing in the rôle of warning prophet. I have endeavored to
free this warning as much as possible, from all technical terms or
scientific methods of speech, for my great desire is, first of all, that
it should be read; and I know by experience that the careless
general reader will never pick his way through the thorns of technicalities,
no matter what beautiful sleeping truths may lie behind them
dormant for a hundred, aye, a thousand years.
But to dispense with preliminaries, I will say at once that about
two years ago the idea suggested itself to me that by the use of the
microphone I might possibly ascertain whether, when a couple of
ants visibly conversed by rubbing together their antennæ, they
produced any sound whatever a sound, of course, far too slight to
reach the human ear. The microphone, I may venture to explain
to those who have not carefully followed the later triumphs of
electrical invention, is an instrument designed to magnify sounds. For
example, if a fly is allowed to walk across the sounding-board of
this instrument the sound is like the tramping of a horse; or rather,
owing to the suction of its feet, which enables it to walk up
smooth surfaces, the sound is like that of a horse walking in deep,
thick mud. It will readily be seen that such an instrument allows
of the catching of vibrations which are too feeble to affect the
unassisted tympanum of the human ear. I experimented with ants
for some time without achieving any considerable success, other
than the perception that a slight crispation accompanies a conversation
carried on by means of the antennæ. Being balked in this
direction, I then conceived the idea of experimenting with bees.
Here I was rewarded with a sudden and most astonishing success.
As is well known, the humming sound given out by bees is produced
by the movements of the wings, not alone in flying, for the bee still
hums while walking over the petals of a flower. These sounds,
when given forth by a bee walking upon the sounding-board of a
microphone, I found to be as loud as the tones of a shrill voice.
After much careful attention I also discovered, to my unspeakable
surprise, that these sounds were arbitrary, were governed by certain
noticeable modulations, and were in fact, as I soon guessed, a
series of noises by which they conveyed their wants and intentions
to each other.
I will not detail the long series of experiments by which I
convinced myself of the truth of this conjecture; but no sooner had I
done so than I became consumed with a desire to gain some definite
idea of the meaning of each one of these sounds. I began by
putting two bees upon the sounding-board, noting down the sounds
stenographically, and then observing, with the utmost care, the
action taken by one bee in obedience to the sounds made by his fellow.
By this method I was enabled to make some faint guess
at the meaning of certain sets of sounds, and the intelligence they
conveyed from one bee to another. The process was one of infinite
tediousness and labor, as may be guessed when I say that for eighteen
months I worked at these experiments, averaging fourteen
hours a day. For, after I had gathered an immense bulk of notes,
much greater toil was necessary to reduce them to form and gain a
clear idea of the meaning of the sounds, their relation to each
other, and the intelligence conveyed by certain arrangements of
them. It seems like a plagiarism from the old folk-tales to assert
that at the end of two years I had learned the language of the bees;
but this is not the first occasion upon which science has verified the
old, blind guesses of fiction.
Their language is but I dare not trust myself to speak of it:
first, because I lack space; and secondly, because I am preparing an
elaborate paper upon the subject to be read before the Academy of
Sciences, and this fascinating topic is there more fully and lucidly
treated than is possible within the limits of a magazine article.
After arriving at a comprehension of what was said, and picking up
many tantalizing fragments of information by what might be called
scientific eavesdropping, I became possessed of an intense desire to
solve, by questioning the bees, some of the problems in their social
economy which have puzzled all investigators. The labor of
composing for myself an instrument of horse-hair and whale-bone (fully
described in the paper to be read before the Academy), which would
give me the power of reproducing the simple sounds of the bee
language, was but a trifle as compared with my efforts to first learn
that language, and occupied me but a brief space.
My first experiment at conversing was with a drone a member
of the hive that had furnished me with subjects for investigation.
The attempt was only partially successful at first; but the revelations
I extracted from this insect were so remarkable, that I made
him the subject of all further questionings, and from him I derived
the facts which I here present as a warning to my fellow-man.
The following was secured by fragments; and I have, for the greater
convenience of my readers, condensed the substance of many
conversations, eliminated extraneous details, and presented it in as
compact and convenient a form as possible.
This very intelligent insect said: "Our civilization is of vast
age. Almost from the first we were gathered into communities,
the methods of organizing which have undergone the most radical
fluctuations. You will be surprised to learn that though many
thousand years ago our form of government was monarchical as at
present, the sovereign instead of being a queen was invariably of my
own sex. And not only was this true, but also the females in most
hives were fewer in number than the males, and did not work at
collecting honey; they were occupied at home in laying eggs and
caring for the young. The work of building the comb and collecting
honey was entirely performed by male bees. I am proud to
say the hexagonal school of comb architecture was invented and
perfected during the male régime, and so far has never been
improved upon. There was a queen, of course; but she performed
only the duties of consort to the king, and of bringing forth eggs
which contained the germs of future sovereigns.
"Possibly the regulations concerning the lives of the females were
somewhat onerous. It is at least certain that they passed their
whole existence within the hive in which they happened to be
born. They ate the honey provided by the males, reared their
offspring, and never sallied forth for either work or play. When
a new hive was formed by a young colony, the females were hastily
conducted to the home prepared and selected by the males, were at
once incarcerated, and never saw the outer world again. The males,
of course, in their search for food went everywhere, and it was not
infrequent for them to endeavor to enter other hives; but a very
strict guard was kept at the entrance, and the enterprise was always
attended with danger.
"In course of time the hereditary monarchical form of domination
became modified, and during the period of turbulence which
marked the transition to elective monarchy, the strictness of the
regulations concerning the females was somewhat relaxed. It was
at that period also, when, in many hives, the number of males had
been reduced by war, that the older and more robust females were
permitted to make short excursions from the hive to procure the
necessary food to keep the young bees alive. Monarchy was finally
quite abolished in all the communities, and the form of government
became entirely democratic. This was followed by an abolition of
all the old rules governing females; they began to share in the
search for food, and took upon themselves the duties of paternity
also. As a result of this more active life on their part, the number
of eggs hatching females began to exceed those producing males;
and with the growing preponderance of their sex they began to
insist upon having a voice in the government of the hive.
"This was strenuously resisted at the time, but at length their
importunities prevailed; and ere-long, from the superiority of their
numbers, the election of the Grand Master Bee lay virtually in
their hands. It was not long before the idea of a female ruler was
suggested and eventually carried out. No male ever again
governed.
"The democratic government lasted a long while, but in time a
return was made to a nominal sovereignty, though the power in
reality remains in the hands of the workers. The whole economy of
our social system was slowly but surely revolutionized. War was
abolished, and by the ever-increasing preponderance of females the
business of providing for the hives was taken out of our hands. As
the females became more and more industrious and obliged to
make longer excursions for food, the cares of maternity became
more burdensome, and the workers shirked it, leaving a few to
perform this duty. Finally, by long process of selection it devolved
upon one female, who was rewarded by a position of nominal
sovreignty. The workers having abandoned the duties, lost in great
part the functions of maternity, and became what you see them
now. There being but one real female in each hive, and war being
forbidden, it became the custom of the workers to destroy the
greater number of the young males, leaving only a few subordinate
individuals called drones.
"I sometimes rebel in spirit against the degradation of my sex,
but masculine indifference and the long habit of subjection has so
enfeebled us that any attempt to regain equality would be fruitless.
There is nothing left for us but to eat, idle, and be content."
As I slowly pieced together this remarkable history, I was overcome
by the hideous suggestions for humanity it contained. It
became evident at once that my plain duty pointed towards the
immediate communication of my discovery in the most public manner
possible; and, as I am informed by those familiar with such
matters, that the literary serials reach a prodigious number of readers,
I have endeavored to overcome the reluctance arising from
ignorance of the graces of style and the form best suited to such
publications, and through their means convey this pregnant warning
to my sex while it is yet time.
ELIZABETH BISLAND.