The Old Melo-drama.
by H Barton Baker
(1836-1906)
HOW
well I can recall the effects produced upon my boyish imagination
by the performance of an old melo-drama! how, breathlessly
I watched the assassins with their long daggers, and short
swords, and gigantic pistols, creeping about the stage, to pizzicato
music, in search of the good young man of the story, who was
concealed behind a tree or a piece of ruin, but who would so
recklessly expose himself to indulge in brief commentaries upon their
movements; what terrible suspense I endured when the pale weird
woman with the black hair, who passed all her life in moaning
and cursing over some mysterious wrong, was attempting, to the
tremulous wailings of the violins, the escape of the lovely captive
from the robber's den; and how I could scarcely suppress a cry
when the robber himself, all boots, buttons and pistols, suddenly
barred their way! Then the great combat at the end, to the
shrieking of fiddles, the blare of cornets, and the beating of drums,
wherein the good young man fought two and sometimes three
ruffians, and, although nearly overpowered more than once,
ultimately succeeded in laying their black wigs low; then there was
the rush on of the lovely captive, red fire and the apotheosis of
virtue trampling upon vice. Very frequently there was a ghost,
who appeared at opportune moments in lambent flames of blue
fire, much to the terror of all the villains, and to the gratification
of all the good people.
The old melo-drama was strictly conventional; the robbers
always wore dirty boots of untanned leather, jackets with many
short tails and adorned with many buttons; long black hair and
beards of burnt cork. It would be a curious ethnological inquisition
to inquire into the origin of the old dramatic idea that
wickedness is confined to black-haired people; since Lady Audley,
however, there has been a run on red. There was no casuistry
about the old melo-drama, no paltering with sin; vice and virtue
were divided by impassable lines; trimming was impossible; you
must be one thing or the other; poetical justice was always rigidly
enforced, the triumph of wickedness was unknown in that world,
and how anybody could be wicked when they knew that a terrible
doom would inevitably overtake them, or how anybody could
think of being otherwise than immaculately virtuous when they
were so well rewarded for it, was one of those problems that could
be referred only to the perversity of human nature.
The name melo-drama, which signifies a play interspersed with
vocal and instrumental music, was first applied by the Italians to
what we now call opera, and between the earliest operas and the
earliest melo-dramas there is a great resemblance; both took
romantic and improbable stories for their plots, and the characters
of both, in the most trying situations, would relieve their feelings
by songs, duets, and concerted pieces. In the course of time the
vocal introductions became fewer and fewer, until these were
dispensed with altogether, and instrumental music alone was used
to emphasise the action. The two earliest melo-dramas in the
English language, "A Tale of Mystery," and "Deaf and Dumb,"
were written by the author of the "Road to Ruin," Thomas
Holcroft; each has a dumb character and much of the action is
carried on in pantomime; barons of the blackest dye of infamy,
terrible assassins, virtuous and hospitable peasants, persecuted
innocents, roaring torrents, thunder and lightning are the
ingredients of these highly-flavoured stage dishes. Both were
produced at the patent theatres and obtained such signal success that
this species of dramatic composition became all the rage, and
nearly every playwright of the day turned his attention to it.
But it was the age of melo-drama; we had just been flooded
with the grim and ghostly literature of Germany, and there was
an insatiable appetite among the public for haunted castles, tyrant
barons, mysterious freebooters. Scott was translating German
ballads, Mrs. Radcliffe and her imitators were pouring forth
copious streams of horror, and the stage, as usual, was by no
means backward in following the public taste. And after all, it
was but a natural reaction from the frigid, arid, lifeless,
blank-verse tragedies, with their interminable speeches and utter lack.
of interest, with which generations of playgoers had been bored
or entertained. Let anyone buy a volume of these off one of the
old book-stalls, where they still abound, and try to read a few
pages, and he will then understand the eagerness with which a
long-suffering public hailed any change which promised life,
excitement, action, and which superseded the dreary classical
stories as rendered by eighteenth century dramatists upon
which every play-writer considered it his duty to try his 'prentice
hand.
Although Holcroft's two works preceded his attempts in the
same line by several years, Matthew Gregory Lewis, the author of
the once famous romance of "The Monk," was really the originator
of the old melo-drama. "The Castle Spectre," produced at Drury
Lane in 1797, crowded the theatre for sixty nights, a most
marvellous run for those days, and was interpreted by some of the
best actors of the period John Kemble, Wroughton, Palmer,
Bannister, Dowton, Mrs. Jordan being included in the cast.
Spectres of the blue-fire school were then untried experiments in
stage effect, and Sheridan, who was the manager at the time, was
exceedingly dubious as to the reception the public might accord
the ghost of the murdered Evelina, and tried very hard to induce
the author to suppress it; but Lewis was obstinate, and the result
justified his obstinacy; the ghost walked in her flame of blue fire,
the audience were awe-inspired and delighted, and an apparition
of some kind was considered henceforth essential to every romantic
play. Earl Osmond became the type of conscience-haunted
tyrants, of usurpers burdened with some awful secret and nightly
pursued by the Nemesis of bad dreams, but whose chief pleasure
during the day seemed to consist in ordering virtuous but abusive
young men to be confined in dungeons beneath the castle moat;
here also, in the person of Earl Reginald, we have the progenitor
of many scores of captive fathers who have spent countless years,
living, it would appear, like Othello's toad, "upon the vapours of
a dungeon," and likewise many other conventional lay figures that
linger in the minds of old playgoers. The language of "The
Castle Spectre" is not so stilted as that of many of its successors;
although written in that peculiar sentimental, vapid diction
which obtained at the period, it is singularly bald and unmodulated
prose. It is remarkable, perhaps, as containing one of the
first protests against slavery heard upon the stage; the speech is
put into the mouth of Hassan, one of the black myrmidons of
Earl Osmond, and is a very favourable specimen of the style of
the play:
"I have been dragged from my native land, from a wife who
was everything to me, to whom I was everything! Twenty years
have elapsed since these Christians tore me away; they trampled
upon my heart, mocked my despair, and when in frantic terms I
raved of Samba, laughed, and wondered how a negro's soul could
feel! In that moment, when the last point of Africa faded from
my view, when, as I stood on the vessel's deck, I felt that all I
loved was to me lost for ever, in that bitter moment did I banish
humanity from my heart. I tore from my arm the bracelet of
Samba's hair; I gave to the sea the precious token, and while the
high waves swiftly bore it from me, vowed, aloud, endless hatred
to mankind. I have kept my oath, I will keep it." Some time
ago "The Castle Spectre" was revived at one of the West End
theatres in order to cast ridicule upon the plays of a past generation.
It would have been about as logical to have given "Macbeth
Travestie" as a specimen of Shakespeare. To understand the effect
produced upon our ancestors by such representations we should
have to reproduce all the conditions under which they witnessed
them, an almost impossible undertaking we must have the
high-falutin exaggerated style of acting which the language demanded,
actors especially trained to deliver it, and, above all, an audience
to whom they could seriously appeal. Fifty years hence, when
the dramatic style has entirely changed, some manager may
revive a favourite drama of the present day, which will certainly
appear equally ludicrous to our grandchildren.
Another famous melo-drama written by Lewis, was "Rugantino,"
founded upon his own romance of "The Bravo of Venice;" which
was taken from a German source, as, indeed, was the case
more or less with all these productions. Does any reader
remember that extraordinary spectral drama, "Raymond and Agnes,
or the Bleeding Nun of Lindenberg," founded upon an episode in
"The Monk"? A most astounding piece of diablerie, banditti,
and creepiness. It is not so many years ago since it was played
at the Haymarket" as an after-piece. Then there was "One
o'Clock, or the Knight and the Wood Demon," also by Lewis.
Only think of the title, and the expectations it would excite
among an audience that delighted in horrors. This work by its
numerous vocal pieces, choruses, songs, duets, fully justified the
term melo-drama: I can remember it being a stock play in good
provincial theatres.
We should scarcely suspect the author of "Gilbert Gurney"
and the "Berners Street Hoax," of being an imitator of Matthew
Lewis, yet he was the author of two melo-dramas, one of which,
"Tekeli," was very famous in its day, famous for its processions
and "terrific" combats; the elder Hook composed some very tuneful
music for it.
One's theatrical recollections need not go very far back to
remember "The Miller and his Men," and O'Keefe's "Castle of
Andalusia" at the Haymarket; only a few years before his death
Buckstone took the latter for his benefit; both were essentially
operatic, and the beautiful music composed by Bishop for the
former piece is not likely to be forgotten. The round "When the
Wind Blows," and the sestette "Stay, Prithee Stay," are among
that composer's most charming compositions; the blowing up of
the windmill and the bandit millers was considered a great stage
effect at the beginning of the present century, and probably
excited as much wonder and admiration among our grandfathers as
did the cave scene of the "Colleen Bawn," or the fire scene of the
"Streets of London," among their descendants, a few years back.
It was melo-drama that first brought in elaborate stage effects and
gorgeous accessories, and during the so-called palmy days of the
Kembles, while a few pairs of dingy "flats,' and a collection of
dingy dresses that had done service for a generation, were
considered good enough for "Hamlet" and "Macbeth," the managers
of the great theatres lavished large sums upon real water, elephants,
horses, supers, gorgeous scenery and dresses to illustrate such
productions as "Timour the Tartar," the "Cataract of the Ganges,"
"Aladdin" not the burlesque, but a veritable, serious drama and
turned the stage into the platform of a menagerie; and the classical
houses were crowded to witness absurdities that a Whitechapel
costermonger would not tolerate now-a-days. As an instance, we
may quote the combat to music, in a drama entitled the "Dumb
Maid of Genoa;" in this the combatants, each armed with a short,
blunt, basket-hilted sword, timed every blow with the orchestra.
Sometimes each note had its corresponding clash, at others the
combatants had to rest their "minim rest," and engage only upon
the beat of the bar. To see them chop at one another in what
was technically called "the round eights," aiming and parrying
blows while turning pirouettes, and performing other fantastic
movements, and stabbing one another to strong "chords," was to see
a thing beyond the power even of burlesque to travesty.
As the minor theatres arose, melo-drama received a new
impetus. Previous to the repeal of the Licensing Act of 1737,
the two patent theatres in the winter, and the Haymarket in
the summer, had the monopoly of what was called the legitimate
drama, and the new houses could perform only such pieces as came
under the designation of "Burlettas;" by which was understood any
kind of play, each act of which contained a certain number of
vocal pieces. These regulations brought forth a series of musical
farces at the more fashionable houses, such as the Lyceum, and
a number of strong dramas for audiences who loved more solid
viands.
The greatest of melo-dramatists, if quantity be the test, of this
latter period was Edward Fitzball. For many years this
indefatigable playwright supplied both major and minor houses,
Covent Garden, Drury Lane, Sadler's Wells, and the Surrey, with
numberless spectacles, librettos, and dramas. His "Floating
Beacon" was one of the earliest, if not the earliest nautical drama
of the kind that T. P. Cooke familiarised our fathers with,
especially written for the glorification of the British tar, and to show
that virtue is not only morally but physically stronger than vice,
since one virtuous sailor was always equal to half-a-dozen "piratical
swabs." It was a wonderful sight to see one of those "terrific
combats," which was always made a particular feature in the bill.
With a sword in each hand, the Jack Junk or the Ben the Boatswain
would attack any number of black-muzzled, long-haired, petticoat-trousered
pirates, who, whatever their other failings might have
been, were not deficient in courtesy, since they never objected to
give their assailant breathing time. Then, with the most
astounding confidence in his own quickness of eye and readiness of
arm, he would sit upon the hilt of his sword, take out his tobacco-pouch,
and refresh himself with a toothsome plug, all the time
heaping upon his foes the most villainous epithets, which they
endured with a patience truly pitiful; or if they advanced a step,
down would come his sword upon one of their feet a process he
called cutting their corns; in fact, he played with them as a cat
does with a mouse, certain the game was in his own hands.
Another curious variety of the melo-drama was "the dog-piece,"
in which the avenging Nemesis of vice was canine instead of
human. The first and most famous of these plays was the "Forest
of Bondy; or the Dog of Montargis," founded upon a well-known
and veritable French story, of which the following is a brief
résumé: Aubrey, a young officer who is in great favour with his
general, is set upon in a lonely part of the forest by two comrades,
Macaire and Landry, who are jealous of the preference shown him,
and, after a furious resistance, is murdered. Aubrey has a fine
Newfoundland dog, which attends him wherever he goes, but which
the villains have enticed from his side and tied to a tree, while
they have committed the crime. The act-drop falls upon the
death of Aubrey; it rises again upon the farm house, where the
young officer has been staying; on rushes the dog, who has contrived
to break his bonds, he jumps over a stile and pulls at the handle of
the bell. Out come the people, one with a lantern, which the dog
seizes in his mouth, and then leads the way to the scene of the murder.
Macaire and Landry are suspected, and in the last scene, while
they are protesting their innocence, on springs the canine detective,
who, recognising no law but lynch law, fastens upon the red
pad that Landry has concealed beneath his throat; grasping the
dog's neck, to make him hold tighter, he rushes round the stage,
then rolls over and over, shrieks "Mussy, mussy!" dog-men always
pronounced the word so-but the faithful animal is inexorable, and
the wretch expires in strong agonies. The new sensation was an
immense success, and consequently dog-pieces and dog-men became
as plentiful as blackberries. Some years ago, one of these latter,
a man evidently of daring imagination, conceived the idea and
carried it out, of altering "Hamlet" into a dog-piece. The melancholy
Prince was attended wherever he went by a faithful "dawg," which
had belonged to his father, and, in the last scene, he saved his
master from embruing his own hands in blood by taking upon
himself the office of Claudius's executioner. It must have been a
novel spectacle to see the wicked king writhing under the fangs of
a Newfoundland dog.
Although resembling it in every point, except that the one
dealt with vice and virtue as they appear in baronial halls, and
the other with vice and virtue as they appear in peasants' cottages
and the back slums of towns, the domestic drama can scarcely be
considered to be an offshoot of the melo-drama; the former owes
its origin rather to the sentimental comedy of the last century, in
which the frivolities of high life were blended with a pathetic story
of poor and persecuted virtue. The works of Cumberland and
Colman the younger, Holcroft, and Mrs. Inchbald afford numerous
specimens of this kind of composition; in the drama the comedy
was eliminated or changed into vulgar buffoonery, and the action
was carried on to musical accompaniment. Neither the tyrant
baron and persecuted heroine of the "Monk" Lewis school, nor the
Jack Junk and piratical swab of the Fitzball, were more absurd
lay figures than the virtuous peasant and the pride of the village
of the old domestic drama. Who does not remember that oppressively
virtuous peasant, who never worked, but passed his whole
time in preaching moral platitudes, who always carried a little
bundle tied up in a cotton handkerchief supposed to contain his
wardrobe at the end of his stick, who was ubiquitous when sweet
Jessie or Rose was attacked by her enemy, the wicked squire?
And oh that wicked squire in sticking-plaster, crinkly boots,
black frock coat and riding-whip-he never moved without a
riding-whip. Wicked as he was he certainly had a hard time of
it; everybody was down upon him; the low comedy man bullied
him; the chambermaid gave him her mind pretty freely, and
sometimes her umbrella; the heroine overwhelmed him with high-
flown denunciations, and the virtuous peasant belaboured him with
his fists, and, what must have been a worse infliction, with his
sermons; nevertheless he was of a hopeful disposition, but limited
vocabulary. "Ha! foiled again! but it is no matter; a time will
come, proud maiden," &c. this was his invariable formula after
every defeat. Then there was the father of the heroine, with an
ovine head of hair to which he was constantly referring. The first
act usually fell upon his cursing his innocent daughter, who had
been lured away by a villain. Of course there was always a
marriage certificate that turned up in the last scene, for there was no
tampering with the proprieties, no Gallic tendencies were allowed,
in these pieces, and if a magdalen was introduced, she was punished
as relentlessly as even one of her own sex could desire. And the
language of these plays! The village maidens spoke in stilted.
heroics adorned with tropes and metaphors, and the simplest
expressions were converted into fine periphrases. But the authors
scarcely exceeded in this respect the absurd diction which the
fashionable audiences of Drury Lane and Covent Garden had
admired half a century earlier in the writings of Cumberland and
Mrs. Inchbald. Fashion in language, like fashion in dress, always
descends in the social scale, and the verbal elegancies of one
generation, like its costume, are the mode of the alley long after
they have been rejected by the fashionable world.
The British public trembled, and wept, and laughed over
these productions, and thought them very delightful until
burlesque exposed their absurdities, and a terrific combat could be no
longer witnessed without suggesting a Guy Faux figure with a
sword under each arm supposed to be through his body looking
out for a soft board to die upon, and afterwards coming to life
again to join in a wild dance; the village maiden could no longer
trip upon the stage without recalling the antics of Thorne and
Terry, and a breakdown. The pride of the village and all her
surroundings still flourish at certain suburban theatres, or at least
at one, where the audience sympathise with them as deeply as ever.
The last home of the old melo-drama, of the "Monk" Lewis school,
west of Temple Bar, was the old Queen's, now the Prince of Wales's,
which was known among actors by the suggestive name of the
"Dust-hole." The titles alone of some of the dramas produced
there are dramatic curiosities. I remember one which particularly
struck me; it was "The Poison Tree of Java; or, the Spectre
Bride and the Demon Nun." I witnessed its performance; I have
no recollection of the plot, but I remember that the villain was
hurled into the corner thirteen times during the three acts while
attempting his nefarious designs, and that I lost all patience with
him for not repenting and trying the paths of virtue, just by way
of experiment, and if only to free himself from the visitation of
such objectionable ghosts.
With the "Colleen Bawn" Mr. Dion Boucicault introduced a new
school of melo-drama, which has since been dubbed the sensational;
in this the actor and the author are subordinated to the scene-
painter, carpenter, and property man, and the situation is made
to depend upon scenic instead of imaginative effects. What a
wonderful hit that water-cave scene made, with its gauze waters,
and double trap which by the way, it is said, was the idea of the
New York stage carpenter, and not of the author; then followed
"The Octoroon," with the burning ship; "Arrah-na-Pogue," prettiest
of Irish dramas, with the ingenious tower set; "The Streets of
London," with the burning house; "After Dark," with the Underground Railway. But in these days, when the Meritts and Pettits
and Simses have grasped the sceptre of the great Dion, all the
sensational scenes just mentioned would no more than suffice for
a single drama, so ravenous have we become for realistic horrors.
Melo-drama, assuredly, is still one of the most popular forms of
dramatic entertainment; it flourishes at Drury Lane, at the
Princess's, at the Adelphi, and sometimes even at the Lyceum, to
say nothing of the theatres it languishes at. But it is not the old
melo-drama; it is sensational, but seldom romantic; it is realistic
to an extreme, and its characters are certainly taken from life,
though from a kind of life concerning the propriety of presenting
which there may be various opinions; poetic justice is still fulfilled
to the end, but vice and virtue get a little more mixed than it
used to with the old writers. Fashions, however, change in stage
art as well as in literature and everything else, and moralise as we
will, we are all equally powerless to resist it; we can no more
recall the old relish with which we read the books and witnessed the
plays of our youth than we could recall the pride we took in the
garments we wore at the time, which we then considered the
height of elegance, and which we should now regard as the acme
of hideousness. As an instance, not so many years had elapsed
between the time that Charles Kean thrilled all London with the
supernatural romance of the "Corsican Brothers," and that of its
revival under Mr. Irving. Many of those who remembered the
first production went to the Lyceum thinking that the old sensations
excited by the rising of the ghost through the famous trap
would be renewed; but with every disposition to be so impressed,
the experiment was a failure; there was no thrill, the delusion
never enthralled us; the peculiar mental condition that these
effects had once appealed to had passed away, and but for the
splendid mounting, which far surpassed all that had been seen
before, and the fame of the management, the "Corsican Brothers"
would have been a dead failure.
H. BARTON BAKER.