THE DOUBLE NAIL MURDERS.
by George Carter Stent
(1833-1884)
In the province of Chihli, at a place
named 'Ho-chien-fu,
, about
350 li distant from Peking, there lived a
man named Chên, who, assisted by his wife,
managed to eke out a very good livelihood
by tailoring. The wife was young and
extremely handsome; her husband on the
contrary was elderly and not over well-looking.
The wife in fact had long disliked her
husband for his age and ill-looks, and to crown
all had long contracted, unknown and
unsuspected by her husband, a liaison with a
young and good-looking fellow named Fêng.
The intrigue went on for a long time, the
wife daily becoming more and more enamoured
of her paramour, and as heartily loathing
and detesting her husband. This so grew
upon her that she determined to free herself
from her husband's hated presence and thrall
at any risk, and to stick at nothing, even
murder, to effect her purpose, and one day
suggested a plan to Fêng to murder her
husband, so that they might live together
without fear as husband and wife.
Now, although Fêng had no scruple in
committing adultery, he could not contemplate
the thought of murder without a
shudder of horror, and would have nothing
to do with so atrocious an act: so he advised
her to dismiss such an awful idea from her
mind, as, if she perpetrated the crime, it
would certainly be found out, and she would
be punished with death; even if she was not
detected, heaven would infallibly punish her
by causing her to feel remorse for the
remainder of her life.
The wife, however, was not so easily to be
turned from her purpose, and told her
paramour not to concern himself at all about it,
as he was so scrupulous, and that she would
manage the affair without his aid and depend
entirely on herself. That same evening, she
made herself particularly agreeable to her
husband, getting him a nice little dinner,
and supplying him plentifully with drink,
which the unfortunate wretch little dreaming
why he was so kindly treated by his
generally sulky wife drank with great gusto
till he became quite intoxicated, and in that
state dropped off into a sound sleep.
After waiting some time to assure herself
of his sleeping soundly, the wife went quietly
into the next room and returned with a
hammer and nail, and carefully placing the
nail exactly at the crown of the sleeping
man's head, she drove it in with several
blows of the hammer; her unconscious
husband dying without a struggle. No blood
came from the wound, and the woman now
set about adjusting the murdered man's hair
so as to conceal the head of the nail. This
was easily effected, and no one, she felt
convinced, would ever suspect that her husband
had died a violent death.
The murderess now alarmed some of her
neighbours, to whom, with much sobbing
and weeping, she described how, after eating
a hearty supper, he had suddenly dropped
down dead. Whatever the neighbours
might have thought they professed to believe
her tale, and some of them stayed to condole
with her.
The next day the murderess dressed
herself in the deepest mourning and appeared
inconsolable for the loss of her husband,
weeping bitterly, especially when any of his
relations arrived, to whom, when asked, she
related the same tale, "that her husband,
after eating a hearty supper, had dropped
down dead."
There was one of her husband's kindred,
however, who was not to be so easily deceived.
He knew some of the antecedents of the
wife, and her unfaithfulness to her husband.
He put it down that there was not a great
many steps in crime between adultery and
murder, and he suspected that the deceased
did not come by his death fairly, though
how he did come by it he was at a loss to
fathom.
He talked the matter over with some
others of his kindred, and impressed them
also with the idea that the poor tailor had
been quietly put out of the way. After
some discussion some of them reported the
affair to a magistrate and desired him to
order an inquest on the body. The magistrate
readily granted their request, and at
once ordered an examination to be made.
The coroner*
inspected the corpse, but
could perceive no wound or other symptom of
having come to his end unfairly, and made
his report to the magistrate accordingly.
The deceased's kindred, however, were not
satisfied with this, but entreated the
magistrate to allow another and closer inspection.
He again acceded to their wishes, and the
coroner again closely examined the corpse
but with no better result.
On returning home the coroner casually
mentioned the matter to his wife, expressing
his annoyance at the trouble he had had,
all ending in no satisfactory result. His
wife asked her husband many questions
concerning the case, and on hearing the full
particulars, expressed her opinion that
something was wrong. She now made enquiries
as to his mode of examining and could not
avoid giving a pish of contempt when he
described the cursory manner in which he
had examined the corpse.
She asked him how many hearts a person
had? To which he replied, "Six, of course."
"There you are wrong," replied she, "for
there are seven, the palms of the hands, the
soles of the feet, the chest and the back, are
the six, but beyond these there is the brain
heart, which makes the seventh." She told
her husband to go the next day and, parting
the hair of the corpse, carefully inspect the
crown of his head, and if he found a nail or
a needle, he would soon see the cause of his
death.
The next day the coroner followed out the
advice he had received from his wife, and
to his astonishment found that she had been
correct in her surmises, for he discovered a
nail driven into the crown of the head.
This discovery caused a great sensation; the
murderess was immediately seized and taken
off to prison, and had not a word to say
to exculpate herself from so atrocious a
crime.
While investigating the case, the worthy
magistrate suddenly asked the coroner how
he had discovered the nail. The coroner
replied that he was indebted to his wife for
the discovery, she having suggested the idea
of looking at the crown of the head on the
previous evening when he had related the
circumstance to her.
The magistrate cogitated for a short time
and then asked the coroner if his wife had
ever been married before. The coroner
thought this question somewhat out of place,
but replied that she had been previously
married, and was a widow when he married
her. The magistrate bade him bring his
wife with him on the morrow, as he wished
to put a few questions to her. The coroner,
failing to perceive the magistrate's motive
for so strange a proceeding, promised
compliance, and went home, and acquainted his
wife of the magistrate's order, but without
observing the disquietude his information
had given her.
On the next day he took his wife to the
yamên, and the magistrate, after a little
commonplace conversation, remarked that
the recent examination had been a great
source of trouble to her husband and himself,
and enquired how she who had never studied,
and who being a woman could not be
supposed to be acquainted with the details of an
inquest, could have suggested where to find
the nail? He further added that she had
evidently had some experience in that mode
of death and had perhaps practised it herself
on her first husband.
The woman changed colour at these words
and became very flurried and excited in
manner; begging her husband to take her
out of the place. The magistrate felt his
previous suspicions fully confirmed by her
present behaviour, and angrily exclaimed,
"Abominable wretch! Your former deeds
have come to light; tell me the whole truth
or I'll torture it out of you!"
The coroner's wife, finding that she had
unwillingly betrayed herself, and dreading
the torture, flung herself on her knees before
the magistrate, confessed that she had
murdered her first husband in that manner,
but pleaded in extenuation his ill-treatment
of her. The magistrate now demanded
where his remains were buried. The woman
gave directions where the grave was to be
found; a party was sent to the place, the
grave was opened and the corpse taken from
the coffin, but having been buried upwards
of three years nothing but bones remained;
a large nail, however, was found deeply
embedded in the skull, proving beyond doubt
that he had been murdered.
The discovery of this second murder caused
more sensation even than the first; it seemed
as if heaven in its inscrutable power and
justice had specially designed that each
murderess should be the direct or indirect
cause of finding out each other's crimes, for
if the first woman had not committed a
murder, the second could never have pointed out
the means of detecting it, and if she had not
done so her own guilt would probably have
never come to light.
The two murderesses were at once sentenced
to the death they merited. The coroner
tried hard to have his wife's sentence
remitted, begging the magistrate to have mercy,
to make allowance for the ill-treatment she
had received and the length of time that had
elapsed since the deed; her repentance and
promises of amendment; but the magistrate
was inexorable, and declared he would shew
no favour "that since she had done so to
her former husband she might also some day
in a fit of passion or pique do the same to
him. Both should be executed; it would be
a caution to other wives, and show them
that even though hid for years murder will
out."
G. C. STENT.
(THE END)