APPARITIONS AND VISIONS.*
by John William Draper
(1811-1882)
*
Being a chapter on Inverse Vision, including
Insanity of the Retina and Cerebral Sight, from A Treatise
on Human Physiology, by JOHN W. DRAPER, M.D.,
Professor of Chemistry and Physiology in the University
of New York. To be published shortly, by Harper and
Brothers.
|
THE perception of external objects depends
on the rays of light entering the eye, and
converging so as to produce images which make
an impression on the retina, and, through the
optic nerve, are recognized by the brain. The
direction of the influences, so far as the observer
is concerned, is from without to within; from
the Object to the Brain.
But the inverse of this is possible. Impressions
already existing in the brain may take, as
it were, an outward direction, and be projected
and localized among external forms. Or, if the
eyes be closed, or the observer is in darkness,
they will fill up the empty space before him with
scenery of their own.
Inverse vision depends primarily on the
condition that ancient impressions which are
inclosed in the optic thalami, or registering
ganglia, at the base of the brain, assume such a
degree of relative intensity, that they can fix
the attention of the mind. The moment that
an equality is established, between the intensity
of these vestiges and sensations contemporaneously
derived from the outer world, or that the
latter are wholly extinguished, as in sleep,
inverse vision occurs, presenting itself, as the
conditions may vary, under different forms
Apparitions, Visions, Dreams, Ecstasy, and
Somnambulism.
From the moral effect to which these give
rise, we are very liable to regard them as
connected with the supernatural. In truth,
however, they are the natural result of that play of
the nervous mechanism which of necessity
produces them whenever it is placed, either by
normal, or morbid, or artificial causes, in the
proper position. It can act either directly, as
in ordinary vision, or inversely, as in cerebral
sight, and in this respect resembles those instruments
which equally yield a musical note,
whether the air is blown through them or
drawn in.
The hours of sleep constantly present us, in
a state of perfect health, illusions which appear
to address themselves to the eye rather than to
any other sense, and these commonly combine
into moving and acting sceneries, a dream being
truly a drama of the night. In certain morbid
states appearances of a like nature intrude
themselves before us, even in the open day, but
these being corrected by the realities with which
they are surrounded, impress us very differently
to the phantoms of our sleep. The want of
unison between such images and the things
among which they have intruded themselves, the
anachronism of their advent, or other obvious
incongruity, restrain the mind from delivering
itself up to that absolute belief in the reality
which so completely possesses us in our dreams.
Yet, nevertheless, such is the constitution of
man, the bravest and the wisest encounter these
fictions of their own organization with awe.
If we measure the importance of events
occurring to us by their frequency, the depth of
the impression they make, the influence they
exert on our own individual career, or have
exerted on the progress of the whole human race,
there are very few more deserving the discussions
of physiology than visual hallucinations.
With respect to frequency, it may be reasonably
said, that if images arise in the mind by night
as thickly as sensible forms present themselves
by day, it is not likely that they should be
better borne in memory. But of the thousands of
objects we encounter each day of our lives, how
few there are that we can distinctly recollect at
its close. We think we explain this wonderful
forgetfulness by saying that we have paid no
attention to them. And, in like manner, the
dreams we remember are perhaps only a very
insignificant proportion of those which have
been presented to the mind.
It has been said that a belief in apparitions
is an instinct with every man. However much
we may dissent from the correctness of such an
expression as broadly given, there can be no
doubt that it has a foundation in truth. The
faith of a child in this particular is only gradually sapped as he grows up to be a man. Nay,
even in mature life, there may always be found
those who have an unwavering confidence in
the reality of these illusions, and many of these
are persons characterized by their moral courage
and love of truth. I have just remarked that
few things have exerted a greater influence on
the career of the human race than a firm belief
in these spiritual visitations. The visions of
the Arabian Prophet ended in tincturing the
daily life of half the people of Asia and Africa
for a thousand years. A spectre that appeared.
in the camp at Sardis, unnerved the heart of
Brutus, and thereby put an end to the political
system that had made the Great Republic the
arbiter of the world. Another that appeared
to Constantine strengthened his hand to the
accomplishment of that most difficult of all the
tasks of a statesman, the destruction of an
ancient faith.
But these were all impostures, it may be said.
Not so, they were no impostures of the persons
to whom they are reported to have occurred,
and who assuredly firmly believed in the real
existence of what they thought they saw. To
the two or three instances mentioned above,
scores of a like kind might be added, which
have issued in the committing of men to the
most earnest kind of work. So often do historians
notice an element of this kind mingling
in the career of those who have made the deepest
mark on our race, that some are to be found
who assert the necessity of such a condition to
any wide-spread and permanent political event.
It is, they say, the want of an intense faith in
some guiding object, which is at the bottom of
all the uncertainties of modern times, and which
is threatening civilization with shipwreck. There
is wealth enough and strength enough on board,
but there is wanting a mysterious needle, which
will point forever in one direction, by day or by
night, in calm or in storm. Whatever we may
think of such a conclusion, the premises on
which it is founded are well worthy of our
consideration. The physiologist is not at liberty
to deny that a lunatic and delirious man have
faith in what they see. Their senses may
deceive them, but they are not impostors. It is
for him to consider how phantoms may arise in
conditions of apparent health, as well as in
states of disease; in the tranquillities of the
solitary man as well as in the feverish excitement
of the enthusiast.
Visual hallucinations are of two kinds: those
which are seen when the eyes are open, and
those perceived when they are closed. To the
former the designation of Apparitions, to the
latter that of Visions, may be given. Dreams,
therefore, come under the latter class.
The simplest form of Apparition is that known
among physicians as muscæ volitantes. These
are dark specks, like flies, which seem to be
floating in a devious path through the air. They
are owing to disturbances or changes in the
retina. They often appear to occupy the dying.
Of Visions the most common, because they
can be voluntarily produced, are those which
depend on the remains of impressions in the
retina and optic centres. If, when we awake
in the morning, our eyes are turned for a
moment to a window or other bright object, and
then closed, there still appears to the mind a
spectral representation of the object, which
gradually fades away. These illusions can be
caused to have, as it were, a movement in the
dark space before us, answering to the voluntary
rotation of the eyeball. Sometimes, when the
light is not sufficiently intense, or the nervous
organs not sensitive enough, the vision does not
make its appearance on the closing of the
eye-lids, but after fastening the attention on the
position in which it is expected to come, it
slowly emerges at last. That it consists in a
real impression which has been registered in
those organs, and is not a mere product of the
unaided imagination, is very clear from the fact
that we may discern, by attentively considering
it, many little peculiarities which we have not
had time to notice in the original object; thus
if there has been a lace curtain, or other such
well-marked body before us, we can not only
see in the vision the places where its folds
intersect the window-bars, but likewise, if the
impression be a good one, all the peculiarities of
its figured pattern. And that our conclusions
in these respects are correct, is proved as soon
as we reopen our eyes.
Between Apparitions and Visions is an
intermediate class, of which it is not my object
now to say much; they may, however, be styled
Deceptions. These take their origin in some
outward existing reality, and are exaggerations
of the fancy. They are commonly encountered
in the evening twilight, or in places feebly
illuminated. Sir Walter Scott says of children
that lying is natural to them, and that to tell
the truth is an acquired habit. If they are thus
by nature prone to deceive those around them,
they are none the less prone to deceive
themselves. To them a white object faintly descried
in the obscurity, is easily expanded into a moving
and supernatural thing.
In a physiological sense, I consider that simple
apparitions arise from disturbances or disease
of the retina, visions from the traces of
impressions inclosed at a former time in the
corpora quadrigemina and optic thalami. In
their most highly marked state the former may
be treated of as results of the insanity of the
retina; the latter, as of cerebral vision.
Disturbance of the retina, brought on by any
cause whatever, may give rise to simple spectral
apparitions, which, as the circumstances
change, will have an indefinite contour or a
definite form. Nor are they merely shades
and shadows; they may be presented in colors,
which however are usually dim or subdued.
Thus, if the eyelids being closed, we press
gently with the tip of the finger on the inner or
outer angle of one of the eyes, a gray spot
surrounded by colors makes its appearance on the
opposite side of the same eye, and dances about
as the pressure of the finger varies. With more
extensive and heavier pressure clouds of various
rainbow tints fill up all the imaginary space
before us. In like manner, the passage of an
electric current from a voltaic pair induces a
flash of light of considerable brilliance.
Internal pressures, and spontaneous variations in
the rate of metamorphosis and nutrition of the
retina, act in a manner analogous to external
disturbances.
From the muscæ volitantes, which may be
regarded as the first rudiments of apparitions, it
is but a step to the intercalation of simple or
even grotesque images among the real objects
at which we are looking; and, indeed, this is
the manner in which they always offer
themselves, as resting or moving among the actually
existing things. I do not undertake to say how
far we are liable to practice deception upon
ourselves after the manner we have spoken of in
children, when we have once detected the fact
that we are liable to this infirmity. An inanimate
object for instance a stick is seen upon
the floor, we go to pick it up, we find there is
nothing there, we return to our first position;
but we can observe no shadow or other reality
that can be offered as an explanation of what
we have seen, still less is there any spectre.
An event of this kind predisposes us perhaps
to return to that disposition of exaggeration so
natural to our early life; and the next time the
retina deceives us, we involuntarily give to the
hallucination motion, and a more definite form.
Insects flying in the air, or rather floating in
vacancy before us, present the incipient form
of retinal malady. It may be provoked by
undue use of the eyes, as reading by lamplight.
I remark it constantly in my own case, after a
prolonged use of the microscope. In a more
aggravated form it less frequently occurs, as
producing stars or sparks of light. From the earliest
times physicians have observed that it is a "bad
sign" when the patient localizes these images.
"If the sick man says there be little holes in
the curtains, or black spots on his bedclothes,
then it is plain that his end is at hand."
Under the title of Pseudoblepsis, or false
vision, medical authors enumerate several
varieties of the foregoing phenomena. But when,
as is most commonly the case, the derangement
which gives origin to these appearances is not
limited to the retina, but arising in some
constitutional affection, involves more or less
completely the entire nervous apparatus of the eye,
retinal insanity and cerebral vision occur
together. In those cases which have been
investigated in a philosophical manner by the
patients themselves, this complication is often
distinctly recognized. Thus Nicolai, the
Prussian bookseller, who published in the "Memoirs
of the Royal Academy of Berlin" an interesting
account of his own sufferings, states, that of the
apparitions of men and women with which he
was troubled, there were some which
disappeared on shutting the eyes, but some did not.
In such a case, there can be no doubt that the
disease affected the corpora quadrigemina and
the optic thalami, as well as the retina.
This condition in which the receiving centres
and registering ganglia at the base of the brain
are engaged, is the one which yields the most
striking instances of hallucinations in which
apparitions and visions coexist. It can, like the
less complicated forms, be brought on artificially,
as in the delirium tremens, which follows a
cessation from the customary use of alcohol, or
in the exaltation induced by the purposed
administration of opium or other drugs. In this,
as in those forms, it is the localization of the
phantom among the bodies and things around
us that begins to give power to the illusion.
The form of a cloud, no bigger than the hand,
is perhaps first seen floating over the carpet;
but this, as the eye follows it, takes on a sharp
contour and definite shape, and the sufferer sees
with dismay a moping raven on some of the
more distant articles of furniture. Or, out of
an indistinct cloud, faces, sometimes of most
surprising loveliness, emerge, another face
succeeding as the former dies away. The mind,
ever ready to practice imposture upon itself,
will at last accompany the illusion with
grotesque or even dreadful inventions. A
sarcophagus, painted after the manner of the
Egyptians, distresses the visionary with the
rolling of its eyes. Martin Luther thus more than
once saw the devil under the well-known form
popularly assigned to him in the Middle Ages.
As the nervous centres have become more
profoundly involved, these visions become more
impressive. Instead of a solitary phantom
intruding itself among recognized realities, as the
shade of a deceased friend opens the door and
noiselessly steps in, the complicated scenes of a
true drama are displayed. The brain becomes,
as it were, a theatre. According as the travel
or the reading of the sick man may have been,
the illusion takes a style. Black vistas of
Oriental architecture, that stretch away into
infinite night; temples, and fanes, and the battlemented
walls of cities; colossal Pharaohs sitting
in everlasting silence, with their hands upon
their knees; and perhaps, to complete the scene,
in a quiet gleam of sunlight, among palm-trees,
the camels reposing. "I saw," says De Quincey,
in his "Confessions of an English Opium-Eater,"
"as I lay awake in bed, vast processions
that passed along in mournful pomp, friezes of
never-ending stories that, to my feelings, were
as sad and solemn as if they were stories drawn
from times before Œdipus and Priam, before
Tyre, before Memphis. And at the same time
a corresponding change took place in my dreams
a theatre seemed suddenly opened and lighted
up within my brain, which presented nightly
spectacles of more than earthly splendor."
Apparitions are the result of a false interpretation
of impressions contemporaneously made
on the retina; visions are the presentment of
the relics of old ones which yet remain in the
registering ganglia of the brain. We convince
ourselves of the truth of this general assertion,
not so well from an examination of one or
more well-related or authenticated cases, as
from what may be termed the Natural History
of Ghosts. The Greeks and Romans of
antiquity were just as much liable to disorders of
the nervous system as we are; but to them
supernatural appearances came under mythologic
forms Venus, and Mars, and Minerva. The
places of these were taken in the dreams of the
ascetics of the Middle Ages by phantoms of the
Virgin and the Saints. At a still later time in
Northern Europe, and even in England, where
the old pagan superstitions are scarcely yet
rooted out of the vulgar mind, even though the
Reformation has broken the system of ecclesiastical
thought, Fairies, and Brownies, and Robin
Goodfellows survived. The form of phantoms
has changed with change in the creed of
communities; and we may therefore, with good
Reginald Scot, inquire, if the apparitions which
have been seen by true men and brave men in
all ages of the world were real existences, what
has become of the swarms of them in these latter
times?
One class of apparitions perhaps it was the
first to exist, as it is the last to remain has
survived all these changes; survived them
because it is connected with a thing that never
varies the affection of the human heart. To
the people of every age the images of their dead
have appeared. They are not infrequent even
in our own times. It would be an ungracious
task to enter on an examination of the best
authenticated of such reports. Inquiries of this
kind can scarcely be covered from the liability
to an imputation on personal veracity, perceptive
power, or moral courage. And, after all,
it is not necessary to entangle ourselves with
these causes of offense. It is enough for us to
perceive that even here incongruities may be
pointed out. The Roman saw the shade of his
friend clothed in the well-known toga, the
European sees his in our own grotesque garb.
The spirit of Maupertius, which stood by the
bay-window of the library at Berlin, had on
knee-breeches, silk stockings, and shoes with
large silver buckles. To the philosopher it may,
perhaps, occur, that it is very doubtful if, among
the awful solemnities of the other world, the
fashions ever vary. Let us pause before we
carry the vanities of life beyond the grave.
From such reflections as the preceding, I
think it may therefore be concluded, that there
are two sources from which spectral appearances
are derived. First: Disturbances of the retina,
which present masses of light and shade, or
colors to the mind; and these are worked by the
fancy into definite forms on the same principle
that we figure to ourselves pictures of faces
among glowing embers. This constitutes retinal
insanity. Second: Gradual emergence from
the registering ganglia of the brain of old
impressions, which are rendered as intense and
distinct as contemporaneous sensations. The
two forms may, however, co-exist. Of the latter
I may observe, that the views of Dr. Hibbert,
in his work on Apparitions, appear to me to
approach nearer to the truth than those of any
other author. It will be perceived, however,
after perusing his interesting book, that I have
not laid the stress he has done on the mechanical
influence of the circulation of the blood,
but have viewed the effect as of a more purely
nervous kind.
As this emergence of old images which have
been registered in the optic thalami is not only
connected with the physiological explanations
we have given of the functions of the brain, but
also occurs under circumstances of such
singularity as to border upon the supernatural, we
may pursue the consideration of it a little
further. It may, I think, be broadly asserted, that
all spectral appearances refer to things that are
past persons who are dead, events which have
taken place, scenes that we have visited; or, if
we have not the actual reality, then pictures,
statues, or other such representatives thereof.
It has never yet occurred that any one has seen
a phantom, the indications of the bodily presence
or representation of which, until that
moment, he had never known. Thus, in the Middle
Ages, the spectres of African negroes were
common enough, but no man ever witnessed
one of an American Indian; yet these, in their
turn, prevailed after the voyage of Columbus.
They were no strangers to the early colonial
settlers. The same may be said of all kinds of
inanimate objects.
As illustrating the manner in which impressions
of the past may emerge from the registering
ganglia, I shall here furnish an instance
which borders close upon the supernatural, and
fairly represents the most marvelous of these
psychological phenomena. It occurred to a
physician who related it in my hearing to a
circle whose conversation had turned on the
subject of personal fear. "What you are saying,"
he remarked, "may be very true, but I
can assure you that the sentiment of fear, in its
utmost degree, is much less common than you
suppose; and though you may be surprised to
hear me say so, I know, from personal experience,
that it can be but little comprehended.
When I was five or six years old, I dreamt that
I was passing by a large pond of water in a very
solitary place. On the opposite side of it there
stood a great tree that looked as if it had been
struck by lightning, and in the pond, at another
part, an old fallen trunk, on one of the prone
limbs of which there was a turtle sunning
himself. On a sudden a wind arose, which forced
me into the pond, and in my dying struggles to
extricate myself from its green and slimy
waters, I awoke trembling with terror.
"About eight years subsequently, while
recovering from a nearly fatal attack of scarlet
fever, this dream presented itself to me, identical
in all respects, again. Even up to this time
I do not think I had ever seen a living tortoise
or turtle, but I indistinctly remembered there
was the picture of one in the first spelling-book
that had been given me. Perhaps, on account
of my critical condition, this second dream
impressed me more dreadfully than the first.
"A dozen years more elapsed. I had
become a physician, and was now actively pursuing
my professional duties in one of the Southern
States. It so fell out that, one July afternoon,
I had to make a long and wearisome ride
on horseback. It was Sunday, and extremely
hot; the path was solitary, and not a house for
miles. The forest had that intense silence
which is so characteristic of this part of the day.
All the wild animals and birds seemed to have
gone to their retreats, to be rid of the heat of
the sun. Suddenly, at one point of the road, I
came upon a great stagnant water-pool, and
casting my eyes across it, there stood a pine-tree
blasted by lightning, and on a log that was
nearly even with the surface a turtle was basking
in the sun. The dream of my infancy was
upon me; the bridle fell from my hands; an
unutterable fear overshadowed me, as I slunk
away from the accursed place.
"Though business occasionally afterward
would have drawn me that way, I could not
summon the resolution to go, and actually have taken
roundabout paths. It seemed to me profoundly
amazing that the dream I had had should, after
twenty years, be realized without respect to
difference of scenery, or climate, or age. A good
clergyman of my acquaintance took the opportunity
of improving the circumstance to my
spiritual advantage; and in his kind enthusiasm
for he knew that I had more than once
been brought to the point of death by such
fevers interpreted my dream that I should die
of marsh miasma,
"Most persons have doubtless observed, that
they suddenly encounter circumstances or
events of a trivial nature, in their course of
life, of which they have an indistinct recollection
that they have dreamt before. It seemed
for a long time to me that this was a case of
that kind, and that it might be set down among
the mysterious and unaccountable. How
wonderful it is that we so often fail to see the
simple explanation of things, when that explanation
is actually intruding itself upon us! And
so in this case, it was long before the truth
gleamed in upon me, before my reasoning powers
shook off the delusive impressions of my
senses. But it occurred at last. For I said to
myself, 'Is it more probable that such a
mystery is true, or that I have dreamed for the
third time that which I had already dreamed
of twice before? Have I really seen the blasted
tree and the sunning turtle? Are a weary
ride of fifty miles, the noontide heat, the silence
that could almost be felt, no provocatives to a
dream? I have ridden under such circumstances
many a mile, and have awoke and
known it.' And so I resolved that if ever
circumstances carried me to those parts again, I
would satisfy myself as to the matter.
"Accordingly, when after a few years an incident
led me to travel there, I revisited the well-remembered scene. There still was the stagnant
pool, but the blasted pine-tree was gone.
And after I had pushed my horse through the
marshy thicket as far as I could force him, and
then dismounted and pursued a close investigation
on foot, in every direction around the spot,
I was clearly convinced that no pine-tree had
ever grown there-not a stump nor any token
of its remains could be seen. And so I have
now concluded, that at the glimpse of the
water, with the readiness of those who are falling
asleep, I had adopted an external fact into a
dream; that it had aroused the trains of thought
which in former years had occupied me, and
that, in fine, the mystery was all a delusion,
and that I had been frightened with less than
a shadow."
The instructive story of this physician teaches
us how readily, and yet how impressively the
remains of old ideas may be recalled how they
may, as it were, be projected into the space
beyond us, and take a position among existing
realities. That such images arise from a physical
impression which has formerly been made
on the registering ganglia, it is impossible to
doubt; and that for their emergence from their
dormant state it is necessary that there should
be a dulling or blunting of contemporaneous
sensations, so that these latent relics may
present themselves with a relatively equal force.
This equalization of the intensity of an old
impression with a present sensation may be
brought about in two different ways: first, by
diminishing the force of present sensations, as
when we are in a reverie, or have fallen asleep;
or by breathing vapors unsuited for the support
of respiration. Second, by increasing the
activity of those parts of the brain in which the
old impressions are stored up. On each of
these a few remarks may be made.
Cerebral vision depends on an equalization in
intensity between present sensations and old
impressions. So long as the former predominate
in power, the latter excite no attention, or
are wholly overlooked. This condition is
illustrated by such facts as that the flame of a candle
held against the sun is utterly overpowered and
imperceptible, but is seen of its proper brightness
when it is in presence only of another
flame like itself. Or as the stars, which are
concealed by day, are plain enough when the
light is withdrawn. Ancient impressions,
harbored in the optic thalami, can not make
themselves felt against sensations just establishing
themselves. For, as when we have looked at a
bright window, and then close our eyes, the
retinal phantom we see becomes paler and paler,
and after a while dies out, so do cerebral images
undergo a diminution of intensity with lapse
of time, though it may be questioned whether
they ever entirely waste away. The law which
obtains in our economy for other organs of
sense applies in these cases too. Even in
contemporaneously occurring sensations, unless
there is something like an equality between
them, the weaker makes no impression upon
us. In the presence of a bright light a less
brilliant one can not be seen; a feeble sound is
made inaudible by an intensely loud one;
minute variations of temperature become
imperceptible when we are submitted to a great heat
or cold. Ideas are no more than the vestiges
of what were once sensations, and are subjected
to the same physiological law. For them to
become embodied, and to cheat the mind into a
belief of their re-existence, equivalent in all
regards to outward and actually existing things,
the impressions of these latter must be diminished
in their power, or the vigor of the former
must be reinforced.
So when we are passing away into sleep, the
organs of sense no longer convey their special
impressions with the clearness and force that
they did in our waking hours, and this gives to
the decaying traces which are stored in the
registering ganglia the power of drawing upon
themselves the attention of the mind. So likewise
in the delirium of fevers, the spectral
phantoms which trouble the sick are first seen
when the apartment is darkened and kept
silent, especially when the patient closes his
eyes. Until the senses are more completely
overwhelmed, these shadows will disappear on
brightly illuminating the room, or on opening
the eyes. And so, too, in the hour of death,
when outer things are losing their force upon
the dim eye, and dull ear, and worn out body,
images that have reference to the manner of
our past life emerge, the innocent and good
being attended in their solemn journey by visions
in unison with their prior actions and thoughts;
the evil with scenes of terror and despair. And
it is right that it should be so.
The enfeebling of sensations which we are in
the act of receiving from external sources, so as
to bring them on an equality with those which
have been long ago impressed, not only occurs
in the condition of sleep and in the article of
death, but may, in a temporary manner, be
established by resorting to certain physical
agents and drugs. Pressure upon the brain,
either accidentally or purposely applied, is well
known to produce such a result, and in like
manner the inhalation of various agents, such
as pure hydrogen gas, the vapor of ether or
chloroform, or other non-supporters of respiration.
On breathing these substances anæsthesia
is soon induced; the external world is shut out;
and on carrying forward the operation to its
due extent, the mind and the brain are literally
left to themselves. Opium acts in like manner,
more particularly in the case of those who
have accustomed themselves to its undue use.
It, however, not only blunts the force of new
impressions, but exerts a positive agency in
intensifying the decaying remains of old ones.
Under its full influence the true relations of
space and of time disappear, a century of events
is lived through in a single night, the vision can
comprehend distances approaching to the infinite,
and yet, in these circumstances, the mind
does not perceive a riot of incongruous combinations, but every thing is presented in a
methodical and orderly way: pictures, all the parts
of which are in just proportions and severe keeping
to each other, and long sequences of events
that maintain a mutual harmony.
But, as I have just remarked, the equalization
of new sensations with old impressions,
which is necessary for phantom appearances,
and the incarnation and outward localization
of ideas, that is, cerebral vision, may take place
by heightening or reinforcing the old impressions
as well as by diminishing the intensity of
the new sensations. And as in the former
case, so, in this, the result can be reached in
many different ways. Whatever will cause
increased functional activity of the cerebral structure,
will recall these old images in force. It
is almost unnecessary to allude to the delirium
that attends inflammatory states of the brain;
artificial experiments are more instructive.
For the purpose of increasing the functional
activity of the cerebral structure, protoxide of
nitrogen, by reason of its greater solubility in
blood, exceeds in power even oxygen gas itself.
This substance, when respired, at once awakens
long trains of vivid ideas, the recollection of all
kinds of former scenes. Its action is divisible
into two periods, the first corresponding to the
heightened sensibility arising from the increased
oxidation it is establishing in the economy; the
second, to the depression which soon comes on
through the consequent accumulation of carbonic
acid, and which the lungs and skin are unable,
with sufficient quickness, to remove. Sir
H. Davy, who first recognized its physiological
power, has given us a graphic description of
these effects. He says: "A thrilling, extending
from the chest to the extremities, was
almost immediately produced. I felt a sense of
tangible extension highly pleasurable in every
limb; my visible impressions were dazzling and
apparently magnified. I heard distinctly every
sound in the room, and was perfectly aware of
my situation. By degrees, as the pleasurable
sensation increased, I lost all connection with
external things; trains of vivid, visible images
rapidly passed through my mind, and were
connected with words in such a manner as to
produce sensations perfectly novel. I existed in
a world of newly-connected and newly-modified
ideas. When I was awakened from this
semi-delirious trance by Dr. Kinglake, who took
the bag from my mouth, indignation and pride
were the first feelings produced by the sight of
the persons about me. My notions were
enthusiastic and sublime, and for a moment I
walked round the room, perfectly regardless
of what was said to me. As I recovered my
former state of mind, I felt an inclination to
communicate the discoveries I had made during
the experiment. I endeavored to recall
the ideas; they were feeble and indistinct. One
recollection of terms however presented itself,
and, with the most intense belief and
prophetic manner, I exclaimed to Dr. Kinglake,
'Nothing exists but thoughts; the universe is
composed of impressions, ideas, pleasures, and
pains.'"
In like manner, the intoxication that arises
from alcohol has two distinct stages, depending
on entirely different phases of its chemical
action. At first there is an exaltation of effects,
because of the increased functional activity
established; but this, after a time, is succeeded
by a dullness, or even stupefaction, attributable
to the impression which the carbonic acid, arising
from the destruction of the alcohol, is making
upon the nervous centres.
By two different methods, therefore, ancient
impressions may be equalized, as respects
intensity, with new sensations. The vigor of the
former may be increased, or the effect of the
latter diminished.
Equalized in any way in their force, the mind
is ready to confound its own ideas and external
forms together. A cause which perhaps might
seem to be too trivial fastens the attention, and
at once a solitary form, or even the machinery
of a long drama, emerges. It is no more possible
for us to say why the thought runs in one
course rather than another, and lays hold of
image after image in succession, than we can
foretell the way of a spark that moves darkling
on
the ashes of a piece of burnt paper. Yet it,
too, runs in connected lines.
No better evidence can be given that the
images we are speaking of are impressions of
past events registered in the brain, and which
gain the power of drawing upon themselves the
attention of the mind, either by their assuming
an unwonted intensity, or by the diminution of
the influence of newly-arriving sensations, than
the philosophical observations by some of those
who have been liable to these infirmities on their
own cases. Thus, in such a case recorded in
"Nicholson's Philosophical Journal," and
alluded to by Dr. Hibbert, "I had a visit," said
the patient, "from Dr. C, to whom, among
other remarks, I observed, that I then enjoyed
the satisfaction of having cultivated my moral
habits, and particularly in having always
endeavored to avoid being the slave of fear. I
think, said I, that this is the breaking up of the
system, and that it is now in progress to speedy
destruction. In this state, when the senses have
become confused, and no longer tell me the
truth, they still present me with pleasing
fictions, and my sufferings are mitigated by that
calmness which allows me to find amusement
in what are probably the concluding scenes of
life. I give these self-congratulations without
scruple, more particularly because they led to
an observation of fact which deserves notice.
When the doctor left me, my relaxed attention
turned to the phantasms, and some time afterward,
instead of a pleasing face, a visage of
extreme rage appeared, which presented a gun at
me, and made me start; but it remained the
usual time, and then gradually faded away.
This immediately showed me the probability
of some connection between my thoughts and
these images, for I ascribed the angry phantasm
to the general reflection I had formed in
conversation with Dr. C. I recollected some
disquisitions of Locke, in his treatise on the
Conduct of the Mind, where he endeavors to
account for the appearance of faces to persons of
nervous habits. It seemed to me as if faces in
all their modifications being so associated with
our recollections of the affections of passions,
would be most likely to offer themselves in
delirium, but I now thought it probable that other
objects could be seen if previously meditated
upon. With this motive it was that I reflected
upon landscapes and scenes of architectural
grandeur, while the faces were flashing before
me, and after a certain considerable interval of
time, of which I can form no precise judgment,
a rural scene of hills, valleys, and fields appeared
before me, which was succeeded by another and
another in ceaseless succession-the manner
and times of their respective appearance, duration,
and vanishing, being not sensibly different
from that of the faces. All the scenes were
calm and still, without any strong lights or glare,
and delightfully calculated to inspire notions of
retirement, of tranquillity, and happy meditation."
The same writer adds, in another place,
"The figures returned, but now they consisted
either of books, or parchments, or papers
containing printed matter. I do not know whether
I read any of them, but am at present inclined
to think that they were not distinctly legible, or
did not remain a sufficient time before they
vanished. I was now so well aware of the connection
of thought with their appearance, that by
fixing my mind on the consideration of
manuscript instead of printed type, the papers
appeared after a time only with manuscript writing;
and afterward, by the same process, instead
of being erect they were all inverted, or appeared
upside down."
We can not fail to remark the close
resemblance between these illusions arising from a
fixed meditation on recollected scenery, and the
phantoms which are witnessed after our gaze
has been steadily directed to some brightly-illuminated
object, as a window, when we first
awake. In both there is the same subdued and
uncertain brilliancy of effect; in both the same
gradual fading away; in both the mind does
not refer the image it contemplates to an inward
point or place, but sets it forth outwardly,
projecting it into the empty or occupied region
beyond. In inverse as in ordinary vision, the law
of the line of visible direction is enforced, and
this reference of cerebral images to a definite
point in outer space, is a phenomenon of the
same kind as the appearance of the invisible
coin on pouring water into a basin, the lifting
of ships into the air by atmospheric refraction,
the appearance of the sun and moon every day
above the horizon before they have actually
risen and after they have set, and many other
optical illustrations that might be mentioned.
Physiology, though full of teleological
illustrations that is, examples of the use of means
for the accomplishment of an end has none
more worthy of consideration than this of inverse
vision. Men in every part of the world, even
among nations the most abject and barbarous,
have an abiding faith not only in the existence
of a spirit that animates us, but also in its
immortality. Of these there are multitudes who
have been shut out from all communion with
civilized countries, who have never been enlightened
by Revelation, and who are mentally
incapable of reasoning out for themselves arguments
in support of those great truths. Under such
circumstances, it is not very likely that the
uncertainties of tradition derived from remote ages
could be any guide to them; for traditions soon
disappear, except they are connected with the
wants of daily life. Can there be, in a
philosophical view, any thing more interesting than
the manner in which these difficulties have been
compensated, by implanting in the very organization
of every man means of constantly admonishing
him of these facts, of recalling them with
an unexpected vividness before him, even after
they have become so faint as almost to die out?
Let him be as debased and benighted a savage
as he may, shut out from all communion with
races whom Providence has placed in happier
circumstances, he has still the same organization,
and is liable to the same physiological
incidents as ourselves. Like us he sees in his
visions the fading forms of landscapes that are
perhaps connected with some of his most grateful
recollections; and what other conclusion can
he possibly derive from these unreal pictures,
but that they are the foreshadowings of another
land beyond that in which his lot is cast? Like
us he is visited at intervals by the resemblances
of those whom he has loved or hated while they
were alive; nor can he ever be so brutalized as
not to discern in such manifestations suggestions
which to him are incontrovertible proofs of the
existence and immortality of the soul. Even
in the most refined social conditions we are
never able to shake off the impression of these
occurrences, and are perpetually drawing from
them the same conclusions as did our uncivilized
ancestors. Our more elevated condition
of life in no respect relieves us from the inevitable
consequences of our own organization, any
more than it relieves us from infirmities and
disease. In these respects, all over the globe
we are on an equality. Savage or civilized, we
carry about within us a mechanism intended to
present us with mementoes of the most solemn
facts with which we can be concerned, and the
voice of history tells us that it has ever been
true to its design. It wants only moments of
repose or of sickness, when the influence of
external things is diminished, to come into full
play, and these are precisely the moments when
we are best prepared for the truths it is going
to suggest. Such a mechanism is in keeping
with the manner in which the course of Nature
is fulfilled, and bears in its very style the
impress of invariability of action. It is no respecter
of persons. It neither permits the haughtiest
to be free from the monitions, nor leaves the
humblest without the consolations of a knowledge
of another life. Liable to no mischances
nor loss, open to no opportunity of being
tampered with by the designing or interested,
requiring no extraneous human agency for its
effect upon every man, but involuntarily ever
present with each wherever he may go, it
marvelously extracts from vestiges of the impressions
of the past overwhelming proofs of the reality
of the future; and, gathering its power from
what would seem to be a most unlikely source,
it insensibly leads us, no matter who or where
we may be, to a profound belief in the immortal
and imperishable, from phantoms which have
scarcely made their appearance before they are
ready to vanish away.
It is scarcely necessary for me to do more
than barely refer to the assertions of those who
would have it believed that they look upon all
these appearances as fictions and deliberate
impostures. What is to become of all history if
such a doctrine could be maintained? Human
evidence must be regarded as utterly worthless!
Moreover, no one denies the existence of dreams,
and the phenomena we have here been treating
of are philosophically of the same order.