HOW MEN DIE IN BATTLE.
War as Seen by a Private or an Observant Turn.
by Frank Wilkeson
(1848-1913)
In Frank Wilkeson's "Recollections of a
Private" in this chapter, which can not fail
to be of greater interest to the average
reader than the war stories which are
written from the standpoint of men who
were not in the fight, or, being there, treat
of the struggle in a general and tactical way:
Almost every death on the battle-field is
different. And the manner of the death
depends on the wound and on the man,
whether he is cowardly or brave, whether
his vitality is large or small, whether he is a
man of active imagination or is dull of
intellect, whether he is of nervous or
sympathetic temperament. I instance deaths
and wounds that I found in Grant's last
campaign.
On the second day of the battle of the
Wilderness, when I fought as an infantry
soldier, I saw more men killed and wounded
than I had before or after the same time. I
knew but few of the men in the regiment
in whose ranks I stood, but I learned the
Christian names of some of them. The
man who stood next to me on my right was
called Will. He was cool, brave
and intelligent. In the morning when
the second corps was advancing and driving
Hill's soldiers slowly back I was
flurried. He noticed it, and steadied my
nerves by saying kindly: "Don't fire so
fast. This fight will last all day. Don't
hurry. Cover your man before you pull
your trigger. Take it easy, my boys, take
it easy, and your cartridges will last the
longer." This man fought effectively.
During the day I had learned to look up to
this excellent soldier, and lean on him.
Toward evening, as we were being
slowly driven back to the Brock
road by Longstreet's men, we made a
stand. I was behind a tree firing, with my
rifle barrel resting on the stub of a limb.
Will was standing by my side, but in the
open. He, with a groan, doubled up and
dropped on the ground at my feet. He
looked up at me. His face was pale. He
gasped for breath a few times and then said,
faintly: "That ends me. I am shot through
the bowels." I said: "Crawl to the rear. We
are not far from the intrenchments along
the Brock road." I saw him sit up, and
indistinctly saw him reach for his rifle, which
had fallen from his hands as he fell. Again
I spoke to him to go to the rear. He looked
at me and said impatiently: "I tell you
that I am as good as dead. There is no use
in fooling with me. I shall stay here."
Then he pitched forward, dead, shot again
and through the head. We fell back before
Longstreet's soldiers and left Will lying in a
windrow of dead men.
When we got in the Brock road intrenchments
a man a few files to my left dropped
dead, shot just above the right eye. He did
not groan or sigh or make the slightest
physical movement, except that his chest
heaved a few times. The life went
out of his face instantly, leaving it without
a particle of expression. It was plastic,
and, as the facial muscles contracted, it
took many shapes. When this man's body
became cold, and his face hardened, it
was horribly distorted, as though he
had suffered intensely. Any person who
had not seen him killed would have said
that he endured supreme agony before death
released him. A few minutes after he fell
another man, a little farther to the left, fell
with apparently a precisely similar wound.
He was straightened out and lived for over
an hour. He did not speak. Simply lay on
his back, and his broad chest rose and fell,
slowly at first, and then faster and faster,
and more and more feebly until he was dead.
And his face hardened and it was almost
terrifying in its painful distortion. I have
seen dead soldiers' faces which were
wreathed in smiles, and heard their
comrades say that they had died happy. I do
not believe that the face of a dead soldier,
lying on a battlefield, ever truthfully
indicates the mental or physical anguish, or
peacefulness of mind, which he suffered or
enjoyed before his death. The face is plastic
after death, and, as the facial muscles
cool and contract, they draw the face into
many shapes. Sometimes the dead smile,
again they stare with glassy eyes and lolling
tongues and dreadfully distorted visages at
you. It goes for nothing. One death was
as painless as the other.
After Longstreet's soldiers had driven
the Second corps into their intrenchments
along the Brock road, a battle-exhausted
infantryman stood behind a large oak tree.
His back rested against it. He was very
tired, and held his rifle loosely in his hand.
The Confederates were directly in our front.
This soldier was apparently in perfect safety.
A solid shot from a Confederate gun struck
the oak tree squarely about four feet from the
ground, but it did hot have sufficient force
to tear through the tough wood. The
soldier fell dead. There was not a scratch
on him. He was killed by concussion.
While we were fighting savagely over
these intrenchments the woods in our front
caught fire, and I saw many of our wounded
burn to death. Must they not have
suffered horribly! I am not at all sure of
that. The smoke rolled heavily and slowly
before the fire. It enveloped the wounded,
and I think that by far the larger portion of
the men who were roasted were suffocated
before the flames curled round them. The
spectacle was courage-sapping and pitiful,
and it appealed strongly to the imagination
of the spectators, but I do not believe
that the wounded soldiers, who were being
burned, suffered greatly, if they suffered at
all.
Wounded soldiers, it mattered not how
slight the wounds, generally hastened away
from the battle lines. A wound entitled a
man to go the rear and to a hospital. Of
course, there were many exceptions to this
rule, as there would necessarily be in battles
where from 20,000 to 30,000 men are
wounded. I frequently saw slightly
wounded men who were marching with
their colors. I personally saw but two men
wounded who continued to fight. During
the first day's fighting in the Wilderness I
saw a youth of about 20 years skip
and yell, stung bv a bullet
through the thigh. He turned to
limp to the rear. After he had gone a few
steps he stopped, then he kicked out his leg
once or twice to see if it would work. Then
he tore the clothing away from his leg so as
to see the wound. He looked at it attentively
for an instant, then kicked out his leg again,
then turned and took his place in the ranks,
and resumed firing. There was considerable
disorder in the line, and the soldier's moved
to and fro now a few feet to the left, now
a few feet to the right. One of these movements
brought me directly behind this
wounded soldier. I could see plainly from
that position, and I pushed into the gaping
line and began firing, in a minute or two
the wounded soldier dropped his rifle, and
clasping his left arm, exclaimed: "I am hit
again!" He sat down behind the battle
ranks and tore off the sleeve of his shirt,
the wound was very slight not much more
than skin deep. He tied his handkerchief
around it, picked up his rifle, and took position
alongside of me. I said: "You are
fighting in bad luck to-day. You had better
get away from here." He turned his head
to answer me. His head jerked, he
staggered, then fell, then regained his feet. A
tiny fountain of blood and teeth and bone
and bits of tongue burst out of his mouth.
He had been shot through the jaws; the
lower one was broken and hung down. I
looked directly into his open mouth, which
was ragged and bloody and tongueless. He
cast his rifle furiously on the ground and
staggered off.
The next day, just before Longstreet's
soldiers made their flint charge on tin
Second corps, I heard the peculiar cry a stricken
man utters as the bullet tears through his
flesh, I turned my head as I loaded my
rifle, to see who was hit. I saw a bearded
Irishman pull up his shirt. He had been
wounded in the left side, just below the floating
ribs. His face was gray with fear. The
wound looked as though it was mortal. He
looked at it for an instant, and then poked
it gently with his index finger He flushed
redly, and smiled with satisfaction. He
tucked his shirt into his trousers, and was
fighting in the ranks again before I had
capped my rifle. The ball had cut a groove
in his skin only. The play of the Irishman's
face was so expressive, his emotions changed
so quickly, that I could not keep from
laughing.
Near Spottsylvania I saw, as my battery
was moving into action, a group of wounded
men lying in the shade cast by some large
oak trees. All of these men's faces were
gray. They silently looked at us as we
marched past them. One wounded man, a
blonde giant of about 40 years, was smoking
a brier-wood pipe. He had a firm grip on
the pipe stem. I asked him what he was
doing. "Haying my last smoke, young fellow,"
he replied. His dauntless blue eyes
met mine, and he bravely tried to smile. I
saw that he was dying fast.
Wounded soldiers almost always tore
their clothing away from their wounds, so
as to see them and judge of their character.
Many of them would smile, and their faces
would brighten as they realized that they
were not hard hit and that they could go
home for a few months. Others would give
a quick glance at their wounds, and then
shrink back as from a blow, and turn
pale, as they realized the truth that
they were mortally wounded. The
enlisted men were exceedingly accurate
judges of the probable result which would
ensue from any wound they saw. They had
seen hundreds of solders wounded, and they
had noticed that certain wounds always
resulted fatal. They knew when they were
fatally wounded, and after the shock of
discovery had passed, they generally lanced
themselves and died in a manly manner. It
was seldom that an American or Irish
volunteer flunked in the presence of death.