ROBBERIES OF NOTE.
The Canadian Bank System of Inspection Has Lessened
the Number of Crimes Committed by Bank
Officials Several Robberies Recalled.
The time will perhaps never come when
monetary institutions will be entirely free
from that dread enemy of society as well
as of the banking system the defaulter.
When the genius, the creativeness and the
skill of the bank manager fashions a
method and evolves a scheme whereby the
checking of the work of the employes is all
the more sure and thereby removing what
might be a possible temptation, the crooked
employe immediately makes use of his
brains to counteract that effect. This he
does with more or less success.
The story is often told here in Canada
of how the teller of one of the savings
banks years ago managed for months, and
years, to keep the fact that he was
even defaulted for a large sum of money a
secret, and how it was discovered by
accident.
TELLER'S PECULATIONS.
From the story which came afterward
it seems that the teller's peculations had
been going on for months, and there seemed
no good reason to believe that he
would be caught. His method was to
credit the correct sum in the books of the
customers of his department, and where
he desired to raise a certain amount he
would credit them on the books of the
bank with just that much less. As long
as he was in constant attendance at the
bank or was not shifted from his position
the risk of being caught was brought down
to the minimum. At that time the inspector
had no system whereby the checking of
the teller's account was at all certain.
Finally, however, another system was
introduced and this consisted in the notification
of the customers by filling out a blank which
read something like this: Your balance at
the close business on (blank date) was
(blank dollars). If incorrect notify the
inspector at once.
THE INSPECTOR'S WORK.
The inspector would then take the teller's
balance sheet and each customer in turn
would be notified. Naturally if a customer
was not given due credit for the amount
which he had in that institution he
would very soon make it known. This was
the check which was relied upon, but which
for a time failed to meet the requirements
of the case, and for the reason that the
Inspector was careless in the disposition of
the notices. With the aid of an assistant
the envelopes containing the notices were
directed and placed in the usual repository
to find their of way the to the post office
in the usual course of the day's business. in the
case in point, however, the light-fingered
teller made free with the mail box and
quietly withdrew the envelopes containing
addresses of accounts
which had been
tampered with. In this manner he was able
to cover up his tracks for some time afterward.
Finally, however, the inspector took
a notion in his head to take these notices
to the post office and mail them himself
and it was then that the defalcation was
discovered.
METHOD OF PROCEDURE.
This same method of procedure is followed
a great many of the Canadian banks at
the present time and is found to be
generally effective.
There is one serious impediment in the
system, however, and that is the trouble
it occasions between the depositors in, for
instance, a savings institution and the bank
officials. In the country districts of the
province of Quebec this has been particularly
apparent. When these notices were sent
out it was found that they brought the
depositor into the city in a great hurry,
and he wished to know immediately what
the trouble was with his account, and then
perhaps he came to the conclusion that the
bank did not wish it any longer. Then
there would have to be long explanations
between the manager and the country
customer. This was all found to be a great
deal of trouble and in a number of cases
it was abandoned for this reason.
MOLSON'S BANK ROBBERY.
The robberies of Canadian banking
institutions have become singularly
prevalent of late. The robbery of the Dominion
bank at Napanee and the celebrated
trial of Ponton is so recent that it is
hardly necessary to refer to it. Then
came the robbery the Winnipeg
branch of the Molsons Bank and the
stealing of some sixty thousand dollars.
Though this robbery occurred between
September 28th and October 4th, 1898, it
remains as complete a mystery as ever,
and though the bank officials hope some
day to lay their hands on the guilty
party, and the best detective talent has
been employed, there is yet no sign that
they will attain
their ends.
ROBBERY OF A LIMA, OHIO, BANK.
About the same time as the robbery of
the Molsons Bank, a Lima, Ohio, bank
was robbed of $75,000 in much the same
manner. In fact the two cases are
almost identical. The Molson's robbery in
Winnipeg is by no means the first one
that has visited that city. In 1883, a man
named Cameron, one of the tellers of
the Union Bank of that city, took $40,000
from the bank one evening, and
drove to the boundary. His method was
bold in the extreme, and he relied on his
legs rather than upon any scheme of
fooling the bank officials. At closing
time on the afternoon in question, he
simply, placed the $40,000 under the desk
instead of into the safe, and when the
opportunity offered that same afternoon
walked off with it.
Cameron made his way straight over the
line with the $40,000 safely stowed away
in a valise. When he was well into the
United States territory the officers came
upon him and he opened up negotiations
for the return of the money. This
Cameron did under the conditions that he was
not to go to gaol. The ex-teller made his
home afterward in Deaver, and died there.
MERCHANTS BANK AT WINNIPEG.
After this came the robbery of the
Merchants Bank of Winnipeg, which was
relieved to the tune of $10,000. This robbery,
however, was believed to have been by
outsiders. Two men entered the bank one
day in business hours and one engaged the
teller in conversation while the other
pretended to read a newspaper in close proximity.
When they left it was found that
the bank was short the sum mentioned.
Just how it was done remains a mystery to
this day and the thieves, if they were the
thieves, were never captured.
Cases in which smaller amounts were
involved have come up frequently, but in
many instances they have never seen the
light of day in fact many more than the
public know anything of have been settled
and the guilty ones have cleared to other
parts. Last August the Bank of Montreal
found itself short some twelve thousand
dollars in the railway department of the
institution. This matter was settled.
BANK NATIONALE ROBBERY.
A man named R. A. Beaulieu, who skipped
out the middle of last August after
robbing the Banque Nationale was not so
lucky. He was arrested on October 15 at
Plattsburg, N.Y., and was brought back
to Montreal for trial. The specific charge
was that he had plundered the bank to the
tune of $250 and he is now serving a
term for the same.
BANQUE DU PEUPLE CASE.
Some ten years ago John Fortier was a
clerk, in the Banque du Peuple and was
found to be short some $1,200 in his
accounts. Efforts were made to settle the
affair, but without success, and finally
Fortier made himself scarce and turned up in
Europe later on. He afterward returned
to America and located in Chicago. Here
he obtained a position with a cloth importing
firm and finally made away with some
of their funds. After this escapade he made
his way back to Canada and Detective
McCaskill captured him at Longueuil. He
was taken back to Chicago for trial.
Another robbery of the unfortunate Banque
du Peuple was committed by Emile
Castonguay. He absconded about July 5,
1894, and has not been seen since.
ST. HYACINTHE BANK ROBBERY.
On April 9th, 1804, the St. Hyacinthe
Bank was robbed of between $11,000 and
$12,000. In this case, however, the robbery
was committed by outsiders and no less a
person than the famous Max Shinburn is
supposed to have had hand in it. Shinburn,
it will be remembered, had a hand
in the Manhattan Bank robbery and afterward
went to Belgium and attempted to
steal the Belgian Court jewels, and came
very near accomplishing it, too, Shinburn
is now in a prison in New York State,
serving a term for robbing a jewelry store
in Albany.
SAVINGS BANK TELLER'S THEFTS
One of the most singular cases in which
an innocent man was brought into case
of embezzlement, took place in Canada
some years ago, but for obvious reasons
the names of the people connected with
it will be omitted, as well as the name
of the bank. The thief in the case was
the teller and his stealings amounted to
something like $35,000. "G," he may be
called for convenience sake, was found to
be a few hundred dollars short in his
cash one day when the examination was
made by the assistant accountant, whose
duty it was to examine the books. The
accountant called the attention of "G" to
the fact, and he said that he would make
it up before the following day that he
had made arrangements to borrow sufficient
money, etc. Months before "G" had placed
the accountant under obligations to him
to the loan of some three hundred dollars,
which he had found it necessary to borrow.
With this obligation staring him in
the face and the fact that "G" promised
to make the shortage good the following
morning, the accountant foolishly reported
"G's" cash as correct. The following day
the shortage was found to be still larger,
and again "G" said that he would make
it good before the following morning. Again
"G's" cash was reported as correct. This
went on for some days, until finally "G"
was short more and more each day. He
finally made bold and told the accountant
that he had reported his cash as correct
all this time he would not now dare to
show, up the deficiency, and as "G" still
promised to make it good the matter ran
along.
It seems that G. was making heavy losses
in stocks and with the persistency of the
born gambler, he always thought that luck
would turn and get him out of the hole.
Matters finally came to such a pass that
the accountant could do nothing be make
a clean breast of the whole affair. This he
did and, of course, was discharged. As his
friends said he was a most decent fellow
and all he needed was a little more
backbone.
TROY BANK SUCCESSFULLY ROBBED.
One of the cheekiest robberies that ever
happened occurred in Troy, N.Y., years ago.
A man named Curley made away with
eighty thousand dollars in bills and soon
afterward was arrested for the robbery. The
authorities, however, could not locate the
money. Curley was tried, found guilty and
sentenced to a long term in prison. The
utmost efforts were made to discover the
missing money, but without avail, and so
two years went by. At the expiration of the
two years Curley made a proposition to the
bank managers which included a division
of the spoils provided they would use their
influence to have him released. This they
refused to do and so two years more went
by and the bank continued its hunt for the
$80,000 and Curley remained in prison.
When he had served his four years,
Curley renewed the offer and this time the
bank officials considered it. They went over
to Albany and had a talk with the
Governor on the subject, and it finally transpired
that Curley was released and retained
$40,000
which he had served the four years
for.
THE SYSTEM IMPROVED.
It is an almost universal custom among
the banks in Canada to compel each of
its employes to take two weeks holidays
each year, and this is found to be an
excellent check on the work of the men.
In this interval a man's place is taken
by another, and of course, if there is
anything irregular it is almost sure to
come out in that time. The bank officials
state that the past fifteen years
has seen decided improvements in the
inspection of banks throughout Canada.
Before that period the inspection was
looked upon as more or less of a farce,
while now it is most thorough and business
like, and tends to impress the
employes with the fact that every precaution
was being taken to safeguard the
institution and indirectly their own
interests.
It is said that the standard of the
banking fraternity in Canada is not
excelled in any part of the world, and that
the moral and intellectual standard is
not to be excelled. That there have been
black sheep among them is but human
and considering the temptations and the
opportunities which they have it is
really wonderful that there has not been
more crimes committed in the name of
the "almighty dollar."